Wood dye or water based stain with Tru-Oil?

klegacy

Member
Hey there:

So I have 2 issues. I have two SH-1 necks. One I made the mistake of using a hybrid stain on which contains sealer, varnish and stain in one product. Wondering if there is any way I could remove this product and get back to bare wood. My other neck is unfinished and I want it to have the roasted maple look and then tru-oil it for a nice smooth feel. What to use for the color? Wood dye or water based stain? Need some advice, so hoping on lots of responses.

Thanks!
 
Best way to remove finish, in my opinion, is sandpaper and elbow grease. I don't like chemical strippers. As for colour, no difference. The tru oil will work well with both.
 
You are 100% right .. about a half hour and I have it back to bare wood! No more hybrid stain. So happy. Now to do it right. So stain and tru-oil will work well eh? I am going for that roasted maple look. Thinking a walnut stain with a few coats of tru-oil.
 
Hit it with the walnut and then sand back lightly until you get the tone you're after, remembering it will darken and amber slightly with the oil. Or if you want authentic 'roasting' you could try blow-torching it. Inherent risks involved with that though.
 
I guess Minwax water based stain will be best with the tru-oil? That hybrid stain never seemed to dry fully. Really sticky, so happy to get rid of it. Picking up the stain tomorrow and got some of the tru-oil already.
 
mwbws_americanwalnut_300.jpg

American Walnut is the color of choice.
 
Good way to see if there are any scratches from sanding? Looks very smooth, but anything I can pre-rub on it to check this. New to finishing, so thought I would ask some questions to be sure. Just wiped it with a micro fiber cloth, and it is really smooth. up to 400 grit, and sanded by hand.
 
My Dad showed me a good trick for surface finishes - on cars mainly, but works well for timber.
Shut your eyes and run your hands over it - if you can feel it, you can see it later...
Dyes will tend to show up scratches and machine marks as darker lines in the finish
 
Would rubbing alcohol work for raising the grain and re-sanding? Or is it worth it to do this? Would this have any effect on stain and oil application afterwards? Also is 400 grit or 600 grit too smooth for application of stain and tru-oil? Perhaps I should do a rougher sanding with 180 or 220 grit?
 
I would suggest you get yourself some Minwax woodstain preparation. Which exact product you need depends on the type of stain you are using. Water based or Oil based. If you chose a water based stain then any wood treatment and/or has to be the same family. Water based or Oil based.
 
Don't use rubbing alcohol. It will suck all the natural moisture out of the wood & will most likely lead to splotchy spots after you stain.
 
The tru-oil site says to use a water based stain. What does the minwax prep do? Curious. Hitting the building supply place tomorrow for sure. Excited to see these necks come to life.
 
Reading about it now. So I think the process will be .. water based prep, light sanding with 220 grit, apply walnut water based stain to get the right tint, light sanding, when I get the right tint, apply tru-oil. Thanks so much for the tips guys. It is really appreciated.
 
On more question guys .. tru-oil on the rosewood fingerboard too? Or leave it as is? Both necks are currently unfinished.
 
On the neck, sanding up to 600 or 800 would be preferable. As the main point of contact on the guitar, the finer sanded the better.
 
Back
Top