Headphones and valve / tube amps

Hey guys and gals,

I want tube sound and dynamics but unfortunately will play mostly through headphones. It seems like most tube amps that have headphone outputs are actually using a solid state circuit, possibly with digital emulation. Does it make any sense to get a tube amp in that case? Are there any good options other than using software amp emulation?

Thanks,
JG
 
I'm getting some great sounds and feel out my Line6 HX Stomp. I use mainly with headphones and it also acts as a fully fledged audio interface with my Mac. Can also be used direct into PA or FrFr speaker for an amp in the room feel. Has stacks more features which you can look into if something you think worth exploring.
 
It's definitely not a tube amp, but I have been using a THR10C for 7 years. It's fantastic for low volume or headphones (I use mine with Audio Technica M50x's). The new THR-II has even more amp models (and 20W stereo output if needed).

As far as I can tell, the amp models are quite good. For example the one modeled after a Fender Deluxe Reverb has all the flubby bass of the original :)

Responds well to picking dynamics and guitar volume adjustments.

The USB provides an audio interface to computer.

No effects loop, but it takes pedals well.
 
Fortunately we are currently living in a golden age of musical instrument technology, so your options are practically limitless.

The bad news is, your options are practically limitless. :confused: :o

Your choices for tube amps with HP out are going to be limited, but solid state amp technology has come so far (even in the last 5 years) there is something for every budget and every player's needs. AND a lot of them sound great!

If you're solely a bedroom/lounge room player, the previous suggestions are great options and there are heaps more that can do double duty for headphone or live playing. The Fender Champion 20 or 40 are great, have a headphone out, aux in and won't break the bank.
What I like most about them is they are just plug & play. There's no faffing around with deep-diving computer interfacing. Just knobs on the front of the amp. (This is what I disliked about the Mustang Series. Too much mucking around with patches and parameters blah blah blah)

It would help to know what your budget is, because there are good inexpensive options or great expensive ones.

I own one of the Fender Deluxe Reverb ToneMasters, and it is effing brilliant!
Yes, it cost nearly as much (or more) as some tube amps, but it is worth it to me. It weighs under 11kg and keeps up with a bass player and hard hitting drummer no problem and sounds as close to my original '64 Deluxe Reverb as any other I've heard.
It doesn't have a "headphone out" but I can connect it via XLR into my mixer or DAW for "silent" playing/recording.
 
Last edited:
A valve pre-amp pedal would do the job nicely. You could plug your headphones direct into the output, or hook it up to an amp in the effects loop, or push the front of the amp into over drive.
Kingsley make some awesome ones. Check out the Squire:
http://kingsleyamplifiers.com/products/pedals/17/

But you'd also need to use it with a cabinet simulator (as they state) with headphones, otherwise you'll get all that HF fizz that sounds awful once you start adding any drive to the sound.

Valve amp headphone outputs use a very simple low pass filter affair, a couple of capacitors and resistors and that's it, to remove most of the frequencies above 6kHz (well I definitely know that's all that Blackstar use). Yes, they'll also use an op-amp to drive the headphone output, but it's just cleanly representing the signal coming from your pre-amp, and not taking anything away. But most valve amps don't have headphone outputs.

If you are going to spend almost all your time on headphones, then either get a solid state modelling amp (they really are very good now), or maybe a valve/tube amp for playing without headphones and some form of stomp or desktop modeller for when you are. But get one of the latest models, as they have all improved considerably since they first came out. For instance, don't get a 10 year-old Line 6 combo. But the Mk 1 and Mk 2 (current) Boss Katana models are certainly worth considering and sound excellent on their own and through headphones.

The Blackstar HT5R is one of the few valve mps that do have a headphone output, and although the speaker emulation is basic, it is useable, and the amp does sound good on its own. But it's only 5W, and although that's more than enough for home use, it's not really enough to gig with unless miked up, and it's never going to sound as nice clean as say a Fender Princeton, Blues Jr or Deluxe.
 
For instance, don't get a 10 year-old Line 6 combo. But the Mk 1 and Mk 2 (current) Boss Katana models are certainly worth considering and sound excellent on their own and through headphones.

I have been tempted by the Katana amps for over a year, but my first-gen THR10C works well enough, and I have patches tuned exactly right for me. Plus I know that if I ever did get something like the Katana I would spend all my time experimenting with different pedal chain simulations and no time playing. They are nice amps though.
 
Plus I know that if I ever did get something like the Katana I would spend all my time experimenting with different pedal chain simulations and no time playing.

Pre-zactly!!!

That's what I love about my Tonemaster DR. It's just an amp. You turn it on, you plug in, and play!
I don't see that one going anywhere anytime soon.

I also have a Roland Blues Cube Artist. The BC's are also very good "high end" solid state amps.
Based on a "certain brand" of 6L6 amps, no whistles and chimes, just an amp. (it does have an FX loop which I like though)
 
Pre-zactly!!!

That's what I love about my Tonemaster DR. It's just an amp. You turn it on, you plug in, and play!
I don't see that one going anywhere anytime soon.

I also have a Roland Blues Cube Artist. The BC's are also very good "high end" solid state amps.
Based on a "certain brand" of 6L6 amps, no whistles and chimes, just an amp. (it does have an FX loop which I like though)

That said, I do find an evening spent tweaking settings to see how they sound very relaxing. I mean, earlier this week I spent an evening swapping clipping diodes in my TS clone :)
 
It probably would (though I can't find anything specific about the typical output voltage level). But you'd still need a speaker emulator between it and the headphone amp unless you only played clean. And of course there's no reverb available either, so you'd need to run a reverb pedal into the preamp.
 
Would the Kingsley pedal work as a line out to a headphone amplifier?

I don't have anything to add to what Simon said, but at $280US + shipping for a Kingsley, you can a get really good contemporary solid state amp for that kind money. It will be way more versatile for what you're looking to do for home playing, and one day you may want to jam with some mates and you'll be good to go.

D'oh!!! Just realised you are in the US!
But I still think an amp is the way to go.
 
Last edited:
I'll definitely check out the modeling amps. It's certainly been a long time since I've used or heard one in person.

That said, if there was a way to get authentic tube response and sound in the signal chain, it would be nice. Kingsley says the preamp pedals need a power amp behind them, not necessarily a speaker load, so not sure if a full cabinet (load) emulator is necessary? I have a pair of powered studio monitors I could use for live if they output anything like a line level signal.

But agreed that the Roland Cube amps look pretty decent on paper and YouTube videos.
 
But agreed that the Roland Cube amps look pretty decent on paper and YouTube videos.

Still don't know what your budget is, but the standard Cube range offer real bang for the buck and reasonable prices. The available features increase with size (and price) but there's something for everybody there.

The Blues Cube models are where they start to get into near tube amp prices.

I use to have one of the older Cube 30's (mid-2000's) and later a Cube 40-GX (2013). Both were very good, and they've only got better with recent improvements in SS technology.
 
Before I knew what was what, my only pedal was a metal zone. I often plugged headphones into the output for silent practice.

For some reason, this is hilarious :D

Possibly because I used to do the same thing, but with a cheap Zoom multifx.
 
Back
Top