Quote Originally Posted by JimC View Post
What I would do is think about how I'm going to play the instrument. That may give you some clues about what will suit you best.
That's a good point. If you need to quickly switch between neck and bridge pickups in the transition between parts of a song, having to push one knob down and the other up seems much harder than flipping a toggle. Plus if you do the knobs in the wrong order (up then down) you will get a volume stutter.