Simon, thanks for your advice on both the finish and the heal.
Finish wise, I've been trying to find some mahogany offcuts to try a few things out on, but I'm struggling. I can get mahogany knife blanks on eBay at a reasonable price, but postage is expensive and/or slow. In Sydney, it seems the timber suppliers who carry mahogany are well outside town. I might just have to go ahead without testing it, on the basis that if it all turns to custard, I can sand it back and start again.
I think I'm going to try your approach with the heal, i.e. not remove it completely, just move the step back towards the body and gently transition it from there. No Dremel for me, so rasp to is ;-)
I've had a chance to spend quite a lot of time on this build over the last couple of days. I got the headstock shaped, the heal shaped, the timber mate on, and a few coats of stain. Here are the results. I can't decide whether I like the striped effect from the stain being taken up unevenly, or whether I hate it. I might have to put a coat of oil on before I decide.
I was aiming for a mahogany / black burst, and I think the black burst part of that worked OK. The mahogany has come out rather pink though. I started with two coats of Feat Watson Mahogany, diluted 1 part stain to 2 parts colour reducer. Then I went around the edges with Feast Watson Black diluted 1 part stain to 3 parts colour reducer, working it in with a separate swab of cloth.
I might add another coat of mahogany tomorrow, and see how it looks then.
Thanks. It's still not sanded flat or polished yet.
I've made some more progress on the finish. Here are a few photos. Lots of coats of Tru Oil, and I've just wet sanded w/ 1200 grit. I think I'l leave it for a week or so now before polishing. The finish isn't perfect by a long way but I'm scared of sanding through again.
I can't decide whether I'll fit the scratch plate or not. At the moment, I'm leaning towards "not". I also have some chrome pickup rings on their way. I haven't set the neck yet - these photos are a mock build.
Looking good. I like the subtleness of the burst.
Making the world a better place; one guitar at a time...
Very unusual and interesting. Nice job.
I think the scratchplate would be a bit too much black. Your chrome rings sound like a good idea.
Build #1, failed solid body 6 string using neck from a scrapped acoustic (45+ odd years ago as a teenager!)
Build #2, ugly parlour semi with scratch built body and ex Peavey neck
Build #3, Appalachian Dulcimer from EMS kit
Build #4, pre-owned PB ESB-4
Build #5, Lockdown Mandolin
Build #6, Sixty six body for Squier
Build #7, Mini Midi Bass
As you’ll have chrome rings, I’d stick with the original general idea and don’t use a scratchplate. But I’d get some silver knobs and a chrome switch tip as well (you may have to buy a new switch that comes with one to guarantee a good fit).
Downside of no scratchplate is that the body will get scratched. So it’s important to wait a good while for the finish to cure and harden properly to minimise the effects if playing on the finish. Alternatively you coukd see if you can get a clear or mirrored scratchplate that will compliment the overall look.