Thanks for the ideas, guys.

I decided I’m just going to make the headstock look as close as possible to an arrow shape with a coping saw and sandpaper. I like the neck I chose because the strings pull across the nut fairly straight, it’s made for the clover tuners I like, and I can shape it pretty close to a traditional shape without removing too much wood.

I might buy a plain large paddle neck separately at a later date if I’m just dying to go for perfect symmetry and a more “accurate” look. Thanks again.