Originally Posted by
Simon Barden
Have you tried any of those Tonerider pickups? I haven't but I often use Irongrear pickups in my guitars. They are a very similar concept to Tonerider - UK designed but built in China, and I've seen very similar comments about both of them on UK guitar forums in the past. There are certainly better pickups, but it's that question of paying three to five times more for maybe a 10% improvement. And sometimes it's not an 'improvement' but just 'different'.
The Irongear 'Blues Engine' PAF-style pickups I put on my Flving-V to replace the nasty Gibson ceramics are just the job for that guitar. I'm also got covered versions of those to put in my ES-3. The vintage Tele types of theirs I put on my Mexican Tele when the pickups on that (TexMex models) went very microphonic, sound slightly better to me than the originals, and the neck pickup sounds really nice and full, and not weak as some Tele neck pickups can do. I did fit a set of the Irongear vintage Strat types to a friends cheap Squier, which sounded just about OK, rather than the change I was expecting, but it might simply have been the guitar. Some guitars just seem to sound bad whatever pickups you put in them.